By Barclay Kruse
NSC Media Director
On March 5, we announced the teams that will be playing in the 2007 Schwan Cup boys' high school hockey tournament, a tournament that is run by the National Sports Center. (Click here to read the news release and see the teams in each bracket.)
We know this information will touch off some spirited debate, and no small amount of second-guessing. In a state with such a passionate interest in high school hockey, no matter what we do, we'll get toasted and roasted by fans who think they can do it better. More likely, many just wonder how we pick the teams, and who gets placed in each bracket.
The man on the hot seat is Pete Carlson, our Schwan Cup boys' tournament director. It's a tough job, but I think if you look at long-term quality, Pete does an excellent job of assembling a powerful field of teams year in and year out.
Our goal, simply put, is the invite the best 24 boys' teams in the state, regardless of class. Some teams pass on our invitation; the most common reason is that they run their own holiday tournament (Roseau being a good example), or they have a long-standing tradition of playing in another holiday tournament (such as the Rochester teams.) And with only 24 spots open, and only eight in the top blue division, good teams will obviously miss out.
But the teams who've become Schwan Cup staples -- Duluth East, Moorhead, Holy Angels, Centennial, Hill-Murray, Edina, to name a few -- are indisputably among the traditional powerhouses.
Once a team is in the tournament, we invite them back if they play well in Schwan Cup and have a solid roster of returning players. Even if a team plays poorly one year, they may remain in the tournament, but may get bumped down a division. Teams that win the red or white divisions are nearly always offered a spot in a higher division. The reality however, is that we can't clean house every year, nor would we want to. Athletic directors and coaches need to know they have a place in a holiday tournament long-term. That's why our roster of 24 teams is more the same than different, year-to-year. From 2006 to 2007, 22 of the 24 teams stayed the same. (New additions this year are Eastview and Stillwater.)
Another major factor is timing. Teams need to know their status by mid-February. We'd love to wait until the results of the MSHSL State Tournament, or even section championships, to slot in our teams, but it's not possible. In case you're wondering, yes, we had already locked things in before three of our 2007 Schwan Cup teams (Holy Angels, Moorhead and Cretin-Derham Hall) were upset in the section finals March 3. Sometimes that happens.
Once the dust settled, seven of our Schwan Cup teams made the State Tournament (Hill-Murray, Blaine, Edina, St. Thomas Academy, Blake, Burnsville, and Orono), and four others lost in their section final. Not bad.
A final variable is coaches' preferences. Coaches with young talent returning often lobby to move up a bracket, and we definitely look closely at those requests, because we want the best teams in the blue division. It happens less often, but sometimes coaches will request a move down, or to stand pat when our preference would be a move up. Suffice it to say, coaches have their own strategies for their teams, and what Pete wants isn't always what they want.
So feel free to debate, just as long as you keep watching.